h1

Dwarfs Are Cool, Since When?

October 5, 2008

It was about the last thing I ever expected out of Warhammer Online, but this is simply the first MMO that has ever made dwarfs cool. Not just for me, but for a lot of folk, considering how well-populated their ranks are and the general enthusiasm I witness for people playing the classes. Sure, that could be because the race boasts two incredibly powerful careers — Ironbreakers and Runepriests — as well as a jury-rigged scrappy runt (that’d be the Engineer), but I think it goes further than that.

Dwarves seem to get the short (no pun intended) stick when it comes to MMOs and RPGs — they aren’t as mysterious as the elves, as well-rounded as humans, as fearsome as barbarians, or as well-groomed as ogres. They fit the role of “angry little man”, sometimes “comic relief”, and more often than not, “meat shield”. You don’t see a lot of the other races protesting when dwarves get sent up to the front line for the initial slaughter, because who will mourn the dwarves?

In MMOs, dwarves present an aesthetic problem — they’re typically short and squat, which isn’t something that society praises these days, and while the male dwarves can hide behind thick beards and at least look like midget mountain men, the female dwarves fight an impossible battle to be found attractive by anyone, including the male dwarves. Sometimes I think that’s why gnomes were invented, so that dwarf players could point to ONE other race and go, “Hey! At least we’re not that!”

Yet WAR’s dwarves seem to sidestep a lot of this negative stigma. I’ve been trying to put my finger on how WAR accomplished this feat, and in doing so I went on a little adventure to trace dwarfs/dwarves in some of the major 3D MMOs up to now:

Pre-MMOs: Dwarves, like all of the best things in life, descend from good German stock. In this case, their mythology (also Norse and Dutch). Depending on the source, dwarves differed in height, but often had a connection with the earth, metalworking, and ancient magic. They were most famously picked up for use by C.S. Lewis (Narnia’s Trumpkin) and J.R.R. Tolkien (LOTR’s Gimli) in the mid-20th century, Disney for use in Snow White, and then adapted as one of the stock fantasy races for Dungeons & Dragons. By the second half of the 20th century, we more or less adapted a standard stereotype of the dwarven race: short, stocky, miners, short-tempered, axe-users, antagonistic to elves, beardy, and (most importantly of all) ale drinkers.

EverQuest Dwarves: If you wanted a good basic front-line fighter, dwarves were it. From an article on Bright Hub:The dwarves of Everquest are short and burly. Their high strength and stamina make them good fighters for a good race, and the high wisdom that goes along with that makes them a significantly attractive race for both paladins and clerics.”

Warcraft Dwarves: Scottish and proud of it, baby! WoW’s dwarves took the D&D/LOTR/Warhammer look and stereotype, and added a few touches of their own, including the Scottish feel and steampunk accessories (such as tanks and guns). They could originally be Hunters, Rogues, Warriors, Paladins and Priests (although to see a dwarf rogue, or a dwarf female, or a dwarf female rogue was a rare thing indeed). The dwarf Hunter became one of the icons of the game, and was featured in the original trailer.

Everquest 2 Dwarves: It’s like they were people made plastic and then shrunk down with Adobe Photoshop. Other than the whole axe-and-beards motif, I don’t see why they even made it off the drawing board.

Lineage 2 Dwarves: What the…? I guess this is what happens when cutsie Japanese/Asian tastes get ahold of the once-proud dwarves: they turn into the weirdest schoolgirls on the planet.

Lord of the Rings Dwarves: Short, humorless and 59% metal, these dwarves made excellent Guardians (LOTRO’s tanks) and featured some of the absolute worst architecture of the game. If you like right angles and ugly decals, this was the race and homeland for you!

Dungeons & Dragons Online Dwarves: “Grr! I’m a dwarf! And I’m mad or something! I look very constipated! I have to cuff all of my jeans because they don’t make them in my size! Grr!”

Dwarf Hamster: Okay, it’s just here to be cute. Awww.

Warhammer Dwarfs: That’s Dwarfs with a “F”, and don’t you forget it, mister!

Like many fantasy representations of dwarves, Warhammer’s dwarfs are on their way out of history (we can thank Tolkien for this cheery attitude), mainly due to their everlasting grudge match with the Greenskins and their fantastically low birthing rate. On the surface, they don’t stray too far from the dwarven stereotypes: they’re short, way into facial hair, all about being stout little tanks, craftsmen of extraordinary talent, and they can’t decide what they like better: beer or fightin’. Like Warcraft (or Warcraft like Warhammer), these dwarfs eschew fancy-pancy magic for cold iron and steampunk sensibilities. You get the sense that if they survive long enough, their war machines and war gadgets represent the future of warfare in this world.

So, really, why are they so cool? It could be that they’re just so omnipresently stubborn, which assaults you through everything in the game: their look, their quests, their tendency to bark out annoyed “chuffin!” swear words when hit. It could be that in a world full of swords and wispy tree-magic, they’re all about firing a blunderbuss in your face or using ancient runes to call forth earth’s power. It could be that in a war, these are the guys you would most want at your backs, sides and front. Mythic’s artists did a pretty great job with the modeling, especially in the armor department, and they escaped the “fat little guy wearing chainmail” pitfall we’ve seen elsewhere.

And whether or not we’ll ever see them in the game, you can’t deny that the suicidal mohawk’d Slayers are just about one of the most awesome classes in the entire Warhammer Fantasy universe.  Bottoms up!

Advertisements

12 comments

  1. Nice article, although I don’t agree that Dwarves don’t look fat. They really do look fat sometimes, heck, my Engy in his starter clothes looked like he was pregnant (yes, this is a he ^^.) The Ironbrekers do look quite fat as well, at least in Tier 1/Early 2.

    Also, do you ever get the impression that the running animation is a bit off? In the starter area (underground) I noticed it a lot, and sometimes I notice it in the Marshes of Madness as well


  2. I play a dwarf in WoW, Lotro, and WAR. The reason being is I like to be silly when it’s time to be silly and I like to kick some backside when it’s time to kick some backside.

    Elfs are far to serious for me and humans are always so well rounded that they just become blah.


  3. Daoc dorfs were grand.


  4. Just have to point out that the Scottish Dwarf was pure Warhammer =) The reason Warcraft had them like that was because of Warhammer from the start. (Plus, IIRC, some of the old dwarf models had the steampunk goggles and such that you speak of)


  5. The myth lives on, I don’t know if dwarfs are cool but they interesting to say the least, in games not in real life.


  6. I loves me some female dwarfs… they’re unique (not that many people play them) and I get the feeling that they are the true MMO superwomen. They’ll put some ale on to brew and a chicken to roast, go outside and kick some major tail, and get back in time to host a huge victory dinner party, all without breaking a sweat. 😀


  7. and I have a dwarf hamster! His name is Spike and he looks just like that one… LOL


  8. Aww.. dwarf hamster!


  9. The way they say “Bloody Hell!!!” just cracks me up.


  10. I’m in an all-dwarf guild in WAR (The Granite Guard on Ostermark), and I’ve never had more fun! WAR has dwarfs down perfect, moreso than any other MMO out there….I’ve never been really “into” dwarfs so much before, but after checking out WAR in beta I decided to jump in – they are great!


  11. The “coolness” in WAR is probably more due to the two popular classes of Ironbreaker and Rune Priest than anything else.


  12. Lineage 2 dwarf females FTW !!!111!!!111!!!111!!!



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: